The Wrong Place for Justice? (Ep. 8, Season 4 Recap)

Ellaria-Sand

The look of true love: Ellaria Sand (Indira Varma) looks on as her great love, Prince Oberyn, fights to the death in Tyrion’s trial by combat. © HBO.

The theme of “The Mountain and the Viper” is justice: justice delivered and justice perverted. The obvious struggle for justice is the trial by combat itself. But the struggle for justice is everywhere. Cersei struggles to find justice for her son’s death. Tywin doesn’t struggle nearly hard enough to deliver justice for Joffrey’s death. Instead, Tywin uses his son’s trial not to punish the real killer but possibly to eliminate a reminder of a betrayal from decades before.

As the crucified — a perhaps perverse form of Daenerys struggle to deliver justice — are finally taken down in Meereen, Daenerys delivers justice to one of her inner circle. And, last but not least, the greatest lords in the Vale descend on the Eyrie to try to get justice for Lysa’s death.

The most moving struggle for justice may be Prince Oberyn’s long quest to get justice for his long-dead sister who was raped and murdered in an act of war, Robert Baratheon’s coup. Perhaps, Oberyn’s quest is a symbolic tribute to all the women over the centuries who have been raped and murdered in times of war. Unfortunately, however, as Tyrion says earlier this season, “if you want Justice, you’ve come to the wrong place.”

The Wall: Mance Rayder’s Army Approaches

At the rowdy brothel Mole’s Town, people make joking references to songs associated with great injustices that we’ve seen: the Bear and the Maiden Fair and the Rains of Castamere. As Gilly fights with the brothel keeper, she hears the raiding Wildlings approach. Ygritte, the red-bearded Tormund, Magnar of the Thenn, and Mance Rayder’s other conscripts whirl into town slicing and spearing down the townspeople and setting thatched roofs ablaze.

Ygritte is the one to clear the brothel. She kills the annoying brothel keeper. Ygritte finds Gilly hiding in the corner behind a curtain, but Ygritte takes pity on her when she sees the baby. Ygritte warns Gilly to be silent and lets her live.

**

Jon and a few of the men of Night’s Watch drink and reflect on their likely fate. No doubt they will follow the fate of the massacred folks in Mole’s Town. Sam is devastated since he thinks that Gilly might have died in the massacre.

Night’s Watch men – 102 in total fighting men—worry they can’t stop the 100,000 man force that is barreling down on them. And, they are probably right.

Meeren/Daenerys: A letter that changes everything

Unsullied captain – Grey Worm’s attraction to Missandei appears to be growing. As the Unsullied and the women bathe in the pond, Grey Worm can’t take his eyes off the nude Missandei. She notices.

jorah

Jorah studies his maps right before Ser Barristan confronts him about the pardon. © HBO

Later on, as Daenerys weaves a headband into her hair, Missandei expresses that she is troubled that Grey Worm was looking at her and admits he seemed interested – despite being a eunuch. But nobody knows if the Slavers took the “pillar and the stones.”

A little while later in the throne room, Grey Worm and Missandei are alone. He apologizes, fearing he frightened her. When Missandei tells him she was sorry he was castrated, Grey Worm replies he regrets nothing. If he’d never been cut, he would never have met Daenerys the great liberator, had such pride of place or met Missandei. His feelings clearly run deep for the beautiful linguist. Although Missandei and Grey Worm serve Daenerys, they are free so maybe they could be together if they wanted.

This romance is a larger theme about the nature of manhood. Jaime feels he is less of a man after the loss of his sword hand. Theon is emasculated by the loss of his “favorite toy.” Tyrion calls himself the “half-man.” Can anyone love these men? It’s not clear they can love themselves.

**

As the Unsullied finally remove the bodies of the crucified lords of Meereen, Ser Barristan receives a royal pardon Robert Baratheon signed for Ser Jorah – and this changes everything. Ser Barristan tells Ser Jorah that he knows he spied on her.

Later, at an audience with Daenerys, Jorah admits he spied on Daenerys. Daenerys won’t forgive him and orders him to leave Meereen by the end of the night or die.

With that perhaps rash act or inability to forgive, Daenerys loses her wisest and most trusted advisor. Jorah was the only one who had a moderating influence on her.

Ramsay Pleases His Father, While Theon Betrays His

The Ironborn hold Moat Cailin, and Lord Bolton needs control of it if he is ever to claim the North. Lord Bolton promised Ramsay forgiveness for castrating Theon and rendering him a useless hostage – if he captures Moat Cailin. And, there’s nothing Ramsay wants more than his father’s approval.

Ramsay’s scheme is to use Theon against his countrymen. Before Ramsay sends Theon into Moat Cailin dressed like a knight, he reminds Theon he is only role-playing. Theon is not reclaiming his role as Prince Theon; he will always be Reek, forever.

Theon is so broken that when he rides up to Moat Cailin carrying the white banner of peace, it is all he can do to say his name.

Moat Cailin has been under siege for some time. The garrison holding the castle have gone too long without food and water. Kenning, the garrison commander, can scarcely stand.

When Theon offers peace, Kenning’s good instincts warn him not to accept. Unfortunately, Kenning’s men stick a sword through his head and accept on his behalf.

Of course, Ramsay is not to be trusted. Once the ironborn accept the peace terms and open their gates, Ramsay’s army flay the ironborn alive.

After his victory, the devious Ramsay proudly presents Moat Cailin to his father, who is thrilled. Lord Bolton has had Ramsay Snow legitimated – he is now Ramsay Bolton and no longer a bastard. Lord Bolton provides him with the papers from King’s Landing to prove it.

Ramsay has finally won his father’s love and acceptance. Will this make the tortured and torture-inflicting Ramsay any kinder?

The Vale: The baby birds leave nest

Petyr Baelish meets with the council of great families of the Vale, who sneer at his low reputation. They remind him he is a money lender, whoremonger, and Lannister bootlicker. They suspect Petyr had a hand in Lady Arryn’s suicide given how soon it happened after she married Petyr. They want to speak to Sansa –  or, rather, “Alayne” as Petyr calls her — whom they believe is Petyr Baelish’s niece.

Sansa testifies before the council. In a moment in which we all hold our breath, Sansa apologizes to Petyr saying she has to tell the truth. Will she finally get her chance at freedom? Sansa admits she is really Sansa Stark. And, then she weaves a very effective half-truth/ lie that effectively protects Petyr.

Baelish only gave her a “peck on the cheek.” Lysa was pathologically jealous and did try to hold Sansa over the moondoor, but then she killed herself.

And, so it is that Sansa saves Petyr. But the real question is why?

sansa

Sansa (Sophie Turner) when Petyr asks her why she saved him. © HBO

Afterward, as Petyr escorts the lords out, he preys on their heightened emotions (after Sansa’s harrowing story). Petyr is trying to rally the lords of the Vale around Lord Robyn and put him forward as a candidate for the Iron Throne. It’s unclear if they buy what he is selling, but they are clearly more receptive to him than before. As part of Petyr’s yet-to-be revealed plan, he sends the cowardly and unwillingly princeling Robyn out into the world to see his kingdom.

As this episode reveals, Sansa has changed, matured, and is becoming a shrewd operator. Petyr wants to know why Sansa helped him. She chose to gamble on the man she knew rather than strangers. She says she knows what Petyr Baelish wants. But, as see when Sansa later descends the stairs in an outfit Maleficent got would envy, it’s clear she knows how to make him think he will get it.

Arya and the Hound Arrive at the Vale

We only catch a brief glimpse of the beloved Arya this episode. As Arya and the Hound approach the Vale, they debate Joffrey’s death. Arya is sad that she didn’t get to kill Joffrey herself. The Hound is vexed Joffrey was killed by poison, a woman’s weapon.

arya-hound-mountain-viper

Arya and the Hound approach the Bloody Gate at the Eyrie. © HBO

When Arya learns after her huge journey that Lady Aryn died three days ago, all she can do is laugh. They are penniless, exhausted, hungry. Of course, their last chance is dead.

Bad mojo may be coming for the Hound who is growing on us. Somewhat ironically, the Hound’s bite wound is infected and he is walking slower. The gods are not on their side.

The Trial

oberyn-martell-mountain-episode-8-trial-combat

The duel between the Mountain and Prince Oberyn Martell. © HBO.

Before the trial Jaime and Tyrion convene in his cell to glug wine, wax philosophical, and ponder Tyrion’s fate. Tyrion believes his champion, Prince Oberyn, can’t beat the Mountain.

When finally the clock gongs the appointed hour, Jaime departs and wishes Tyrion luck: this may be the last he sees him.

At the combat arena, Tyrion finds Oberyn swilling wine with his paramour, Ellaria Sand. But, Ellaria freaks when she sees the Mountain “You’re going to fight that. He’s the biggest man I’ve ever seen.” And, she’s right to be afraid.

Prince Oberyn whirls around the arena, lithe as a dancer, and flips like an acrobat with his spear. He even shows off a little to please the crowd.

The entire time they fight Oberyn is thrilled: finally justice for his poor sister. Oberyn, a seasoned mercenary, is more than a match for the Mountain. And, this makes him cocky.

charles-dance-tywin-mountain-viper

Tywin (Charles Dance) delivers the verdict. © HBO.

With a flying leap through the air, Oberyn spears the Mountain through the chest in what appears to be a death blow. Oberyn demands the Mountain not die yet and pulls the spear from his chest. “Who gave you the order?” Bent on justice, Oberyn circles the Mountain. But Oberyn walks too close. He isn’t paying attention.

The Mountain shoots out a massive gauntlet-clad hand and trips Oberyn. Oberyn falls. Quick as lightning, the Mountain pins Oberyn under him. The Mountain’s two massive thumbs plunge deep into Oberyn’s eyes. Blood gushes everywhere as he gouges out Oberyn’s eyes. The Mountain then squeezes Oberyn’s head so hard it explodes.

The gods have made their will known, as Tywin tells us. While Cersei smiles evilly down from the stands, Tywin sentences his son to death.

 

 

Jamie Adair is the editor of History Behind Game of Thrones, a website about the history behind George RR Martin's "A Song of Ice and Fire" novels and the hit TV show, "Game of Thrones."

11 Comments

  • Reply June 2, 2014

    Grant

    Tywin seems to actually be the second biggest loser in all of this. He might have gotten rid of the guy who was pushing the most for vengeance and a politically inconvenient killer, but in exchange he’s guaranteed that the Martells will despise the Lannisters for decades if not centuries. Now, the Martells probably would have been coldly neutral anyway, but if he had given them Clegane he might have at least bought real neutrality from them and not what’s going to be a desire to exploit any weakness shown. Another case of winning the war but losing the peace.

    As for the women, I don’t know what Martin or the writers might have meant when they created it, but I doubt Oberyn ever thought much of the women raped and killed in the civil wars of his continent with the sole exception of the former queen. Vengeance for family, but not justice for women.

    Lastly, sorry Missandei but if this follows the books on that, they take away the ‘pillars’ too.

    • Reply June 2, 2014

      Jamie Adair

      Oh right I get what you mean. Isn’t that clever? Yes, the smart thing for Tywin to have done would have been to somehow rigged it so Oberyn would win. Imagine if the Mountain had named who gave the order? I don’t think he does this in the books either. (I’ve read the scene a couple of times, but I don’t remember that specific detail.)

      Yes, you are absolutely right about Oberyn not caring about raped women in general. I meant more that Martin may have created the character as sort of a tribute. Maybe this is just fanciful thinking on my part, but I’d like to think that is the case.

      • Reply June 4, 2014

        Olga Hughes

        The women in Westeros are treated abominably as opposed to how women are treated in Dorne. The Dornish are far more civilised that the barbaric society that is Westeros.
        Elia’s rape and murder is touched on many times throughout the books, as if to emphasize that no-one, not even a queen and her royal children, are safe from the horrors of war.

        • Reply June 4, 2014

          Watcher on the Couch

          Olga is right. Women are (as they were in medieval Europe) second-class citizens in most of Westeros. I like the show but one thing that irritated the heck out of me was the way Talisa cheeked Robb the first time she met him on the battlefield – like you would speak out of turn to a king in that society and not be reprimanded for it. It annoyed me before I had any book knowledge of ASoIF so at that time I didn’t know she was a “show only” character. If she’d spoken to Joffrey that way instead of Robb her head would pretty soon have decorated a spike. That’s not to say there weren’t some feisty females around in the real world in those times – as there are in “Game of Thrones”.

          Isn’t there something in the books about one of the previous Princes of Dorne having opened the water gardens to everyone because his wife Daenerys (an earlier one, not the dragon lady played by Emilia Clarke) had remarked that children bathing were much the same whether they were from rich or poor background?. I can’t remember whether Oberyn’s line to Cersei “We don’t hurt little girls in Dorne” is from the books but it does come across as sounding authentic.

          • June 4, 2014

            Olga Hughes

            I don’t think Oberyn and Cersei had any interactions in the book, I don’t remember any. However I understand the sentiment. Elia’s horrible death is probably weighing on cersei’s mind when Myrcella is sent to Dorne.

            The Water Gardens are a beautiful symbol of Dornish society. Yes they were built by Prince Maron as a wedding gift to his Daenerys and she wanted children of all ranks to be able to play together.

          • July 8, 2014

            Pat F.

            Considering what might happen to Myrcella in the show next season (and did in A FEAST FOR CROWS), Oberyn’s line is ironic. I do believe that both the original and TV versions of Oberyn intended no harm to her, though.

        • Reply June 4, 2014

          Jamie Adair

          I loved this comment – and all the comments on this thread actually. If memory serves, GRRM has said that Dorne is supposed to be a cross between Moorish Spain and the Welsh marches (border towns).

          Coincidentally, I’ve been listening to Teofilo Ruiz – a reknowned American medievalist – lecture about medieval Europe (Crisis and Renewal from Audible/Great Courses) on the way to work. Just today, he was talking about women’s role in Castillian society and noting that women were more equal (possibly than in the North – he didn’t comment on Northern Europe but I think that *might* have been implied). I’d need to check again but it sounded like they were a) out in the fields working side-by-side with the men and b) could own property (even if they weren’t widows). I don’t know how unique the working in the fields is because most peasant women worked in the fields throughout Europe AFAIK. In France, they peasants continued to use sickles and not scythes because women could wield them more easily.
          If women’s rights in Castille and other Spanish regions is why GRRM has that quality in Dorne, I’m (yet again 🙂 ) impressed.

  • Reply June 3, 2014

    Lucas de Melo Facó

    When confronted by Prince Oberyn Nymeros Martell (the brother of Princess Elia Martell), who repeatedly asserts that “Her name was Elia of Dorne. You raped her, you murdered her, you killed her children,” Gregor’s only concern (besides killing him) is that the man has gotten the order of events wrong.

    “Her name was Elia of Dorne. First, I killed her screaming whelp. Then I raped her. Then I smashed her fucking head in. Like this.”

    • Reply June 4, 2014

      Watcher on the Couch

      I don’t know an awful lot about medieval Spain outside the bog-standard things everybody knows, though I read a book many years ago (long enough for me to have forgotten both author and title unfortunately, so am unable to give the reference) which mentioned that there were women scribes in Moorish Spain before the Moors were driven out of that country.

      • Reply June 4, 2014

        Jamie Adair

        Oh that’s really interesting. I’ll have to see if I can dig around and find that. It is amazing what you can turn up between Google Scholar and Google Books, so I probably will be able to track it down. Thanks!

  • Reply June 4, 2014

    Jun

    One thing Martin takes meticulous care in the books is to demonstrate that some (not all) deaths have wide and long-term consequences. Some people may have died but they live on in the minds of the living.

    Elia Martell Targaryen’s murder is one of those deaths that cast a long shadow in this world. Others may include Ned and Joanna Lannister’s deaths. Elia and Oberyn were very close, and Oberyn apparently harbors some guilt about blowing off her many suitors on the trip with their mother many years ago that ended in disaster in Casterly Rock. More than the family vendetta is the historical background that the Dornish are a proud people and have always been suspicious of the rest of Westeros. They had been proud when their princess became the queen of the Seven Kingdoms and must have felt personally insulted and humiliated when their royalty was raped and murdered by a lower class instrument of the Lannister army.

Leave a Reply